Charlotte's Web

Blogging my world since 2006

A Woman in Berlin

15 Comments

Französiche Dom, Gendarmenmarkt, Berlin

I love Berlin. It is so fresh, vibrant and exciting that you feel you are soaking up innovation, ideas and history through your pores as you walk the streets. Berlin has not papered over its cracks, so you see remnants of the Second World War (the bombed-out carcass of the Kaiser-Wilhelm-Gedächtniskirche) and the Cold War (the long, chilly footprint of the Wall) everywhere. I learned that none of the trees in the Tiergarten are more than sixty years old, because the previous forest was razed for firewood in the dying days of the war, and in the freezing winters afterwards.

But this is not about me. During my last visit, I fell upon an amazing book – A Woman in Berlin – a diary of a woman who details her life in the falling city as it was sacked by the Russian army. It starts on 20 April 1945 and ends on 22 June 1945. The writer, who has recently died, chose to remain anonymous when it was published, and the book received controversy, especially in Germany where it was accused of “besmirching the honour of German women.” As you read, you understand why the book might have been hard to swallow in the 1960s. Not only does she describes in exact and excruciating detail what it is like to live in a city under attack: the scrabbling for food, the nauseating fear of being bombed, the chilling anxiety of waiting for the Russians to arrive, but she deals very frankly with the mass rapes that took place, saying that the women began to ask each other not “Were you … ?” but “How many times … ?”.

According to the introduction, over 160 000 Berlin women were raped as the Russians swept through the city. They were considered an acceptable booty for the travails of being a soldier, and all women of all ages are targetted. People in the writer’s apartment building spirited their daughters away in crawl spaces, while only the oldest women ventured out into the streets to fetch water. The writer herself is not spared, and she finally makes a Faustian pact, singling out the most senior – and potentially most cultured and gentlemanly – Russian officer she can find to act as protector. In exchange for sexual favours, she receives food which she shares with the elderly and ailing residents of the building. What Berlin’s liberators come to call “forced intercourse” becomes her only method of survival.

The writer is a journalist and photographer, and her prose builds unforgettable images of war. This means the book can be hard going, since the subject matter is almost unbearable, but it is leavened with her salty sense of humour and astonishing courage.

Here is one excerpt that moved me with its prescience:

I barely glanced at the news from the western front. What does it matter to us now? Our fate is rolling in from the east and it will transfer the climate, like another Ice Age.

On hunger:

I found a letter wedged inside a drawer, addressed to the real tenant. I felt ashamed for reading it, but I read it all the same. A passionate love letter, which I flushed down the toilet. (Most of the time we still have water.) Heart, hurt, love, desire: how foreign, how distant these words sound now. Evidently a sophisticated, discriminating love-life requires three square meals a day. My sole concern as I write these lines is my stomach. All thinking and feeling, all wishes and hopes begin with food.

On the futility of technology:

Our radio’s been dead for four days. Once again we see what a dubious blessing technology really is. Machines with no intrinsic value, worthless if you can’t plug them in somewhere. Bread, however, is absolute. Coal is absolute. And gold is gold whether you’re in Rome, Peru or Breslau. But radios, gas stoves, central heating, hot plates, all these gifts of the modern age – they’re nothing but dead weight if the power goes out. At the moment we’re marching backwards in time. Cave dwellers.

This is a powerful and heart-rending book. It’s also an amazing piece of social history and now that Germany has learnt to be more open about its past, now that other countries have faced up to their roles in the making of war, this is a good time time to be reading this book. It may deal with a very short and very specific period in German history, but it talks to all of us about how far we will go when we are starving, about the bleak impact war has on civilians and about the small sparks of humanity that help people to survive when that seems impossible.

About these ads

Author: charlotteotter

Novelist, feminist, crime writer

15 thoughts on “A Woman in Berlin

  1. Yes, an absolutely horrific period made worse by the fact that raping the women continues to be a strategy of war. I keep meaning to read Anthony Beevor’s Berlin – the Downfall 1945 — apparently a really traumatic read.

  2. “we are marching backwards in time.” As I write this I think about the people living in Cuba and Zimbabwe (and I’m sure many other places) where they find that the electricity is cut yet again, where bike and horses are more reliable than a car due to fuel shortages.

    Sometimes it seems society takes one step forward and two steps back.

    Yet, somehow people’s spirits seem to survive.

  3. Charlotte, thanks for the tip. What you’ve written makes me want to read the book, and I happen to have another book about that same era waiting to be read. Sounds like they might be good back-to-back.

  4. Thanks Charl for making the idea of reading the book more palatable.. so far I have thought that I just cannot stomach all the horror and anarchy of retreating and advancing armies. Maybe I will try and read it. However, I do think this book is important in many ways (much like the film ‘Die Flucht’), as a further significant step in the Germany’s Dealing With the Past. Wasn’t it controversial more because it took the newer line of Germans also as victims of the NS regime and its results and not only as collaborators or criminals? I think this is important, as it reminds us of the quite literally *untold* suffering of the civilian population during war.

  5. During WW2, “Germany” was referred to as an entity – they were the enemy. One forgets that many German men were forced to fight or work for the Nazi Regime and woman and children were left to face the Russian forces alone. I had the honour of hearing the family war stories from my husband’s grandmother before she passed away at the age of 92. She had to make the decision to leave her home in East Prussia with her aging mother, daughter of 4 years,son of 18 months and flee on foot to Germany to escape the Russian Forces. I am sure there are many stories like hers but it gave me a different perspective on the war.

  6. Thanks for the tip – I have ordered it to read over the summer – have you read Stasiland by Anna Funder? Very moving.

  7. Wow, I’m definitely adding this to my reading list. Thanks for mentioning it.

  8. Unfortunately raping has been a spoil of war since time immemorial, no matter how civilized a culture thinks it is.

    That excerpt about hunger reminded me of the scene in The Pianist where a can of peaches is like gold.

  9. i don’t know what it is about today, but every blog i read adds at least one book to my tbr list -this one is going straight to the top!

  10. Sounds like a terrific book, Charlotte. I’ve added it to my list of must-reads!

  11. The rape part reminds me of daily life in South Africa. I suppose we are at war between those who have choice and those who do not. If Germany can turn around in 60 odd years then this gives me hope for South Africa.

    I wonder if a silent, undeclared war makes it easier or more difficult to change?

  12. hi Charlotte
    I just finished to read the book. Didn’t see the movie. I share your thoughts…here are my feelings about the book and why every young person eligible for vote should read it.

    http://berlinromexpress.wordpress.com/2008/11/28/a-woman-in-berlin-la-ciociara/

    ciao from Rome (and sometimes, Berlin)
    StripedCat

  13. I love Berlin and the fantastic S-bahn and the turkish bakeries!

  14. Hello Hello…
    on a completely different note, i read another book about another woman in berlin…the Holly Golightly of the 30s…”The girl of artificial silk” by Irmgard Keun (friend of Doeblin and Roth).

    http://berlinromexpress.wordpress.com/2008/12/29/breakfast-at-kadewe/

    quite interesting!! the historical moment is very hidden in the background (just a hint or two to “nationalist” behaviours), but definitely worth reading!

    ciao!
    StripedCat

  15. Pingback: The State of the Blog « Charlotte's Web

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 187 other followers